How to Choose a Responsible Dog Breeder: Questions to Ask & Red Flags to Avoid

Bringing a puppy home is an exciting and emotional decision—but it’s also a big responsibility. One of the most important first steps is knowing how to choose a responsible dog breeder who prioritizes health, temperament, and lifelong support.

The breeder you select plays a huge role in your puppy’s future. Unfortunately, not all breeders operate with the same standards of care. Whether you’re looking for an allergy-friendly family companion or a potential therapy dog, asking the right questions—and knowing what red flags to avoid—can help you make an informed and confident decision.

At Shasta Royal Monroe, we believe in empowering families through education—even if you don’t get a puppy from us. So here’s our honest guide to choosing a responsible dog breeder you can trust.

How to Choose a Responsible Dog Breeder: Questions You Should Always Ask

1. What health testing do you do on the parent dogs?

A responsible dog breeder should be able to tell you exactly which health tests they’ve done—like OFA hips, elbows, and eyes, plus a full genetic panel specific to the breed. Make sure they can show proof, not just say “the vet said everything looked fine.”

2. Can I meet the parents or see where the puppies are raised?

This isn’t just about cleanliness—it’s about transparency. Seeing how puppies are raised gives you insight into their early socialization, the breeder’s standards of care, and how well-adjusted your puppy is likely to be.

3. What kind of socialization and training do your puppies receive?

Early experiences shape a dog for life. Ask if the breeder uses programs like ENS (Early Neurological Stimulation), introduces puppies to new sounds, surfaces, and people, or begins crate and potty training before go-home day.

4. How do you match puppies with families?

Responsible breeders don’t match puppies based on color or gender alone. Look for someone who considers each puppy’s temperament and matches them to your lifestyle and goals.

5. What kind of support do you offer after the puppy goes home?

Great breeders don’t disappear after pickup day. They should offer guidance, check-ins, and stand behind their puppies with a written two-year health guarantee covering genetic and congenital conditions.

They should also include a spay/neuter contract—which protects the integrity of the breed and ensures dogs aren’t bred irresponsibly.

A responsible breeder will also commit to the lifetime of the dog—not just the sale. At Shasta Royal Monroe, we promise that if one of our dogs ever needs to be rehomed, we will take them back—no questions asked. We never want to see one of our dogs in a shelter or passed from home to home.

6. Can I review the contract in advance?

A clear, thoughtful contract protects both the breeder and you. It should outline the health guarantee, spay/neuter requirements, and what happens if circumstances ever change.

7. Are you affiliated with a breed club or professional organization?

Membership in reputable associations (like ALAA or WALA) shows that the breeder is committed to breed integrity, continuing education, and accountability.

Red Flags to Avoid When Choosing a Dog Breeder

• No health testing or vague answers like, “Our vet says they’re healthy.”

• Puppies available immediately with little screening or explanation.

• Refusing to let you visit or FaceTime to see where puppies are raised.

• Breeder rushes you or pressures you into sending a deposit.

• Puppies sent home before 8 weeks of age.

• No written contract—or one that only protects the breeder.

• No two-year health guarantee.

• No spay/neuter agreement or refusal to discuss breeding rights.

• Breeder shows no interest in your lifestyle or how you’ll care for the puppy.

• No willingness to take the dog back if needed.

Bonus: Extra Signs You’ve Found a Truly Responsible Breeder

Once you’ve confirmed the basics, it’s worth noticing the extras that set truly exceptional breeders apart. These reflect a breeder who goes above and beyond because they genuinely care about the dogs and your experience.

1. Microchipping Before Go-Home Day

A responsible dog breeder often microchips puppies before they leave so they’re protected in case they ever get lost.

2. Health Insurance Trial Offers

Many reputable breeders partner with companies like Trupanion or AKC Pet Insurance to offer a 30-day free insurance trial.

3. Starter Kit or Care Package

This might include food, a familiar blanket, toys, training tips, or a transition guide—all to help your puppy adjust smoothly to your home.

4. Transparency About Their Vet

Don’t hesitate to ask what vet they use and whether they have a good working relationship. Many will gladly share their vet’s contact info for a reference.

5. Strong Online Reviews and Testimonials

Look for consistent positive reviews on Google, Facebook, Instagram, Good Dog, or ALAA. These tell you a lot about a breeder’s integrity, communication, and care.

The Bottom Line

If you’re wondering how to choose a responsible dog breeder, remember—it’s not just about finding a cute puppy. It’s about choosing someone who puts the health, safety, and success of their dogs (and their families) first.

A great breeder isn’t just selling a dog; they’re investing in a lifelong relationship with both the puppy and you. They’ll ask you questions, welcome yours, and be there to support your journey as a dog owner.

At Shasta Royal Monroe, we’re proud to raise Australian Labradoodles with heart, science, and purpose. We health test, temperament test, and guide each puppy through early training to give them the best possible start. And if life ever throws you a curveball, know that your dog always has a safe place to return to with us.

Ready to learn more or take the next step?

Contact us here, or take our free Puppy Personality Quiz to see what kind of puppy is right for you.